Trusts and maintenance

SHARE:

Trust-to-trust: Is a trust an option to ring-fence a maintenance obligation upon divorce?

Reprinted from iol.co.za, by Phia van der Spuy – 2021-11-04

A trust has various uses. A trust is a useful tool to utilise in a divorce settlement whereby a divorce settlement can be transferred into a trust and be applied for the benefit of typically minor children and a spouse.

If a person is obliged in terms of a Court order to transfer assets into a trust, it is unlikely that Donations Tax would be leviable on that transaction since it is not motivated by pure liberality or generosity – a requirement for the application of Donations Tax.

An inter vivos trust

Such a trust is an inter vivos trust, which is established during a person’s lifetime in order to manage certain assets or investments and support the beneficiaries in terms of the Court order. The legal principles applicable to inter vivos trusts are to be found in the Law of Contracts. This means that the principles that apply to the execution of a valid contract also apply to the execution of a valid trust instrument.

The objective of this type of trust is usually to provide an income for the beneficiaries or to provide funds for housing, care, maintenance, education, general welfare, recuperation, health, entertainment, pleasure, or the advancement of the life of any beneficiary. It is also used to transfer assets to the capital beneficiaries (i.e. the beneficiaries who may receive trust assets and profit on the sale of trust assets) during the lifetime and upon the termination of the trust. After the trust instrument is signed, the trust is registered with the Master of the High Court in whose jurisdiction most of the assets are situated or where the administration is to take place.

Beneficiaries

The Trust Property Control Act does not define a beneficiary and is relatively silent as far as matters regarding the beneficiaries of a trust are concerned. It is more concerned with the administration of the trust by the trustees. The nature, number, and rights of beneficiaries are accordingly determined with reference to the trust instrument and our common law. If there is any conflict, the common law will prevail.

Any natural person (unborn or alive) can be a beneficiary of a trust. If a minor (a person under the age of eighteen) is a beneficiary, they must be supported by a guardian when a beneficiary’s decision is required. This should be kept in mind when the trust instrument is drafted, as one may not want the ex-spouse to interfere and hinder the purpose for which the trust was set up, as well as the smooth running thereof.

Legal precedent

In the Estate Welch v Commissioner for Sars case of 2004, more than R 3 million was transferred to a trust for the maintenance of the ex-wife and their child in terms of the divorce settlement. The Court held that the transfer of assets was not a donation, which would have triggered Donations Tax. The ex-husband received an undertaking from the trustees to discharge his liability resulting from the Court order, thereby ensuring that the assets were not transferred to the trust without an obligation.

Mr Welch had established a trust for the benefit of his former wife and son in terms of their divorce agreement. Mr Welch died before having transferred the obligatory funds into the trust, so the executors were obliged to do so. Sars treated the payment as a donation by the executors, who ultimately prevailed in the Court in showing that they had performed an obligation and did not make a donation.

But what made their life more difficult than it should have been was that Mr Welch had included himself and his other children as discretionary beneficiaries as well, although the trust instrument indicated that the trust had been established in pursuance of the provisions of the divorce agreement. The Court was of the view that the other children’s expectation of receiving any such payment was only a spes (hope) and not easily quantifiable for the purposes of Donations Tax.

Mr Welch would have been better advised to have created two classes of beneficiaries:

  • The first being his former wife and son as primary beneficiaries; and
  • Himself and his other children as secondary beneficiaries, to be considered only after the obligations to the primary beneficiaries had been satisfied.

Conclusion

A trust may therefore be an effective tool to ring fence a maintenance obligation, both during one’s lifetime as well as after one’s death. It may prevent abuse by an ex-spouse and children, as the assets will be managed by a board of trustees for the benefit of the beneficiaries in terms of the Court order.


For more information about setting up a trust

Legal advice is essential in setting up a trust. Cape Town law firm Simon Dippenaar and Associates can help you with all aspects of trust registration and administration. Give attorney Simon Dippenaar a call on 086 099 146 or email sdippenaar@sdlaw.co.za.

Further reading:

Previous post:
Next post:
Disclaimer

The information on this website is provided to assist the reader with a general understanding of the law. While we believe the information to be factually accurate, and have taken care in our preparation of these pages, these articles cannot and do not take individual circumstances into account and are not a substitute for personal legal advice. If you have a legal matter that concerns you, please consult a qualified attorney. Simon Dippenaar & Associates takes no responsibility for any action you may take as a result of reading the information contained herein (or the consequences thereof), in the absence of professional legal advice.

Need legal assistance?

Request a free call back

SD Law Auto-assistant

How can we help you?

Please select an area of practice:

  • Divorce
  • Eviction - I am a Landlord
  • Eviction - I am a Tenant
  • Bail/Criminal matter
  • Liquor Licence
  • Other →

How can we help you?

Please select an area of practice:

  • Corporate Law
  • Property & Real Estate
  • Antenuptial Contracts
  • Wills & Estates
  • Immigration/Visa
  • Magistrates & High Court
  • Motor Vehicle/Accident Claims
  • Other/General Enquiry
← Back

Let us call you back

Complete the form below and we will call you back:

Step 1 of 2

← Back
NEED HELP?
Click here